Keep Yourself Alive starts with a chugalugging, heavily phased palm muted chord, joined by a flashy riff, louder, closer until the band's all there and they ramp it up to a fourth above. A brief clearing of the stage. Freddie comes in with a growl both rough and melodic. It's a litany of experiences. He was told million times, the sold a million mirrors, he ate a million dinners, he loved a million women etc. The chorus bursts into the major key with a call and response of the title. What might at first sound like a corporate hippy anthem of try and try again carries a shade more darkness in the suggestion of the great opposition that the whole cosmos might as well be pushing back with. It's a fun and fast rock song with show off playing (Brian May modestly but firmly demonstrating his guitar arranging skills and tone shaping in the solo and Roger Taylor getting a micro solo on the drums) but also a statement of defiance. They're singing to the listener from their own experience (and a little hubris: their trial and error is nothing on Bowie's).
Doing Alright is a legacy of the pre-Queen band Smile. Mercury takes the vocal to a liminal space between head voice and falsetto before the rest of the vocal members and multitracking come in with glorious harmonies. The mood and rhythm break with a diversion into a kind of sunny Latin shuffle which escalates into a crunching electric riff and metal version of the whimsy. Back in first verse land it's all light melancholy and sweets. Big riff breaks in again for a solo on top before a clean finish on the chorus. At one point this might well have been a song Brian May sang in the shower but by the time it got to the second track of Queen's debut disc it is presented as a showcase of harmonies, sudden turns and virtuoso guitar playing.
Having begun with something single-worthy, then the school concert intro to the band, they move on to a number that would only ever be an album track. Great King Rat starts with a crunchy minor key riff that opens up with a reverby acoustic and distant lead vocal. The creation of space and light in the arrangement and production is impressive when you consider that the modal tonality and motion of the lyric could have most easily be squeezed down into a kind of sea shanty. Here it is widescreen cinema. The subject of the song might be a gangster or just some wideboy Mr Sin who lived hard and played deadly. The chorus includes a corruption of the Old King Cole rhyme, giving it more intrigue and atmosphere. And then the middle section (too long and distinct to be a middle eight) which crashes and changes to a major mode as Freddy sings like a herald with lines from GKR's life about being a bad guy to get ahead (pretty much the opposite sentiment to the opening track). This ends with a trailing wordless vocal and patted acoustic guitar moment before we crash back into the last verse, guitar solo (ending in a burst of studio applause) and final chorus that ends with a fade out on a tom tom roll.
My Fairy King closes the first side with the kind of showcasing we've already heard in Doing Alright but bigger and wider. Rhythm changes, new melodic material , instrumental workouts, more of Brian May's wind quintet guitar tone, some impressive piano performance and lots and lots and lots of harmonies. It's easy to dismiss a track like this as showing off but it's worth recalling a few things about the time, also. 1973 might well be associated with glam rock but it is also a time when the prog bands were gigantic enough to have their live gear moved in road trains with the name of each member emblazoned on the the roof of the semitrailers. To stand out in this environment and avoid any possible charge of cashing in on camp or glam you needed to show that you could not only arrange like a 19th century composer but play every note perfectly AND provide a kind of mythos for any characterisation you included in the lyrics. If this had ever been a simple singalong it quickly got the Queen treatment. The great apotheosis of this, Bohemian Rhapsody, would not appear for a few albums and years on and by its time was prepared and recorded by a band with some rapidly acquired discipline. Until then, the world got things like this which, as calculated as it had been, sound mostly like a mess, as though Andrew Lloyd Weber threw an uncooperative rock opera out the window and went back to the drawing board. Beautiful vocals and fine playing but also very astutely placed at the end of a side of vinyl.
Side two begins with Liar. which begins with a drum pattern that the song proper when it begins ignores for a more Who-like powerchord workout made for the kind of venues where the band wanted to headline. A little calm then Freddy comes in with lines from a confession which are answered by the choir calling "liar!" The point at which Freddie wails, "nobody believes me!" and it's a small milestone. All good singers have one thing in common; they make every vocal about themselves. You might be the most proficient, have the most unassailable falsetto, be able to shatter wine glasses with your highest chest voice note, but if you can't make something, whether written for you or you found under a caravan, sound like you, then you don't get to join the greats. Sometimes this is self-fulfilling like Leonard Cohen or Bob Dylan who only ever could sound like themselves and only every sang their own lines. Mostly it's the preserve of the tiny few. When Freddie complains that nobody belieeeeves him (I'm hearing it in his scansion as I type) it comes straight from him. By the time we get to the Oh Sinnerman call and response he finally sounds like the Freddie Mercury we would know and love, not just a skilled vocalist. Perhaps it also had to do with the enhanced tightness of the arrangement on this song which never strays too far from its own path in stark contrast to the previous track. It's as though they started on side one as a good band learning their trade and became Queen on side two.
The Night Comes Down begins with a gorgeous acoustic guitar workout. After a quick flourish from the Brian May orchestra, the vocals start with a refreshing acoustic vamp. Freddie's vocal takes us through a nostalgic trek before the choir enters with the chorus, plain but delicious. Plain, does what it says on the tin but it's a good tin. Brian May song and lovely for all that. It ends with a dazzling Brian multi-geetar serenade.
And bumps right into a thing that would be a feature of every Queen album until Jazz, the Roger Taylor rocker. John Deacon, on bass, was the only one who didn't sing lead vocals. Brian May did but not for a while. That left Freddie Mercury whose command of his voice had no equals on the face of the earth. So Roger went the other way and tried for a mix of Ozzie Osbourne and Robert Plant. Modern Times Rock and Roll charges like a mad bull for less than two minutes and doesn't waste a nanosecond. the breathless charge of it presaged the kind of full throttle of early punk. I bet no early punk acknowledged this, though.
The other thing that Brian May did was big metal songs. Son and Daughter is one of those, combining a big sinewy riff, crunching verse chords and a big bright chorus. The narrator complains about societal roles and the futility of pushing back against it. Why the chorus about wanting someone to be a woman? Maybe, after all that struggle he wanted love and sex to be simple. Absolutely no idea. Probably just sounded good sung. The guitar workout at the end is especially refulgent, casting more aural light than any so far on the record.
Jesus establishes a slamming two chord figure over which Freddie sings a fairly straight account of the fame of Christ. It's impassioned, serious and thoroughly hooky. Freddie wasn't remotely Christian but I tend to think he knew his audiences were acquainted with the bible story and probably admired the legend of the prophet, his power and adoration as a kind of bronze age rock star. This song features the kind of double speed instrumental section known and loved by numberless garage rockers but, considering the skill of the guitar playing, it's painstaking tonal setup and leaning toward atmosphere rather than chops it resembles most closely the Jeff Beck period Yardbirds. It's a stunning act of rock guitarism which yet gives way to a straight reading of the final verse and chorus which ends acapella until the fade.
The final track is an instrumental preview of the early single The Seven Seas of Rhye (fully realised on the following album) and is a softened anti climax after Jesus but pleasant for all that.
I didn't know this album until after I had my first Queen album A Night at the Opera. I'd heard Bohemian Rhapsody in the school holidays between '75 and '76. First week back at school, after hearing everyone else had heard it, too, a casually occurent wish was fulfilled when the video was on Countdown. It was as good as I remembered it. A few weeks later I bought my US pressing from Ken Herfords Import Records around the corner and luxuriated.
And then, as every teenaged kid does, I had to get the rest of them. From memory, it was II then this one, then Sheer Heart Attack by which time the sequel to Opera, A Day at the Races, had come out. So, while I didn't hear them all at once it was in a squashed time period and they all pretty much blended ... except for this one. As the inadvertent effect was of a band sounding as though they worked toward and finally achieved their own sound in the space of one album, it felt like a first effort, the scene in the movie (of any rock biopic) where someone knocks something over, comes up with a phrase of future import, stumbles on a riff or whatnot and the rest is hysteria.
But it was more like the opposite; the band had moved from this self-imposed image to the next, taking on players and singers (like Freddie) until at this point in their career they recorded these songs and struck upon their personality and sound. One of the things that is very notable. here, is that, for all the feeling around on the first side, there is a consistency that does form and a tone, character and weight that will take them to choose their strengths and present in sharper focus with each new effort. This is what happened with Queen. It wasn't the soaring development of a Beatles but for the first decade at least, no flab or filler either (ok, the John Deacon songs but a few of those were massive hits). And there was enough in the tank for the band that got to worldwide number one with a novelty single and only got stronger from that point. While they're clearly serious about their work in this first record it will always, after what followed, sound like workshopping rather than worldbeating. That said, find any rock band that wouldn't be proud enough of this to feel that they could just stop here.