I've already written about the importance of this album to me and described the songs
here. This post is about the 2022 issue of the various new mixes, bonus tracks and packages of The Beatles' centre of gravity moment between superpop flight and the stratospheric orbits: Revolver from 1966. Yes, I'm sick of the hype, too, but as soon as I got back into this one through listening to the new tracks the experience was refreshed and I'm back.
This will take the following form: track by track notes of the new stereo mix, notes on the bonus session tracks of the super deluxe edition, thoughts on the presentation of the mono original and whatever else I didn't get to say here. The atmos mix mostly presents the songs as settled expanded stereo with very little gimmickry. I'll only add notes about it where there is more to say than that.
So, the songs:
STEREO
A mixed bag but I note that the same kind of thing has happened here as on the Pepper and partial White Album mixes in that the levels and features of the original mono mix have been kept but are just now in stereo. That said, this didn't seem dogmatic in those releases (you need the "blisters on my fingers" shout at the end of Helter Skelter which the original mono omitted). Overall, a robust effort that is friendly to headphone listening and speakers alike.
Taxman
This sets the standard of the new stereo as it centres everything we expect, bass, drums and vocals. McCartney's funky bassline provides an engine room and Harrison's stabbing chords hit at precisely the same time as the snare. The double tracked Harrison vocal is solid and the weedly wobbly guitar solo is a little more of an imp. What crowns this arrangement, though, is the vocal harmonies, which open windows to great light.
Eleanor Rigby
The silvery harmonies and crunching strings work superbly well in the more modern stereo here. McCartney's ice cold vocal doesn't suffer from the glitch of the initial stereo mix and jump channels but is allowed to recount the quiet horror of the lives in the song at the centre of the field.
I'm Only Sleeping
The big breezy dream of this one glides with thumping bass, cool harmonies and the same backwards guitar parts as the mono mix (i.e. more of them).
Love You To
Another great one for vocal harmonies which in this song add a kind of chanting gravity. The indian instruments have more complexity and the volume swell of the distorted guitar reinforce the drone of the tambura, adding a modernity to the song.
Here, There and Everywhere
Vocal harmonies lifted much higher than the early mixes but I don't mind as they are so shimmeringly beautiful. For the first time I think that the chromatic guitar figure in the middle eight is actually a 12 string. It's far more subdued than anything from the Hard Day's Night jangle, possibly on the neck pickup instead of the usual heavily compressed bridge from that sound.
Yellow Submarine
If you thought Ringo's pitch was wince-inducingly off in this number you will not be pleased to hear that no pitch control was harmed in the making of this film. There he is, a couple of hairs flat of the higher notes until the others come in with the harmonies for the chorus. More sound effects that, on the original mono mix, were meant to be light and cute but are now unignorable.
She Said She Said
I was looking forward to this one and have to say it's a let down. The song remains as lovely and airy as ever but the panning is so wide that it leaves the centre too open and all that rocking dialogue between the bass and great Ringo performance has been made more polite than it should be. See also the surround mix of Helter Skelter on the White Album reissue which bizarrely played down the bristling Bass VI track that added such force. It's nice to hear it without the distortion that always bothered my ears but this goes too far.
Good Day Sunshine
The piano really has some air around it. The sound of it is so rich. The effect overall is a blend of a piano and an electric guitar with the tone down at zero which adds a lot of punch to the jauntiness of the song. It's an example of the new mix revealing detail that also threatens the structure and force of the original idea. Still, it's a pleasure to hear.
And Your Bird Can Sing
As with all the vocal harmony forward songs this benefits from the airy expansion. The other famous aspect of this one is the dual guitar lines. This feature lifted the staid 12 string progression of the first arrangement and was a progression from the unison solo in the previous album's Nowhere Man where two Strats played as trebly as they could get through the progression and ended on a famous and sublime harmonic. Here the parts are harmonised and a lot busier and would have been murder to learn and get right. To my knowledge this time it's George and Paul playing them.
For No One
A full stage is struck between the piano and clavichord with McCartney's vocal plaintive in the centre, the opposite of the coldness of his delivery in Eleanor Rigby. You might notice the slight percussion more as well as the bass. The French horn croons with an oddly mournful sweetness. This really benefits from the new mix approach.
Dr Robert
The stereo expansion reveals just how gloriously tight the band could get. Improved bass hits the kick drum beats while the guitar stabs match the snare to perfection. Even the arpeggiating jangly guitar which isn't required to fall in so exactly is precise.
I Want to Tell You
A lovely expanded stereo stage allows this strange one from George to really breathe. Bright light harmonies lift it even better than the closely grouped effect of the contemporary mix.
Got to Get You Into My Life
The brass is big and bold and clean. One thing I only registered as a kind of boom between verses is now more definitely the guitar with pulsing down strokes.
Tomorrow Never Knows
This is the one that really benefits from a revised stereo mix as the triumphantly weird sounds and effects work well moving around a central bass drums and vocal to create a kind of trippy space.
SESSIONS
I won't go through these track by track. There are a fair few callbacks to the second Anthology Box for tracks like the early versions of Tomorrow Never Knows and Got to Get You into My Life, the giggling take of And Your Bird Can Sing. There is a lot of perfunctory representation of the tracks as songs in development or arrangements in the making but there are some standouts.
I loved hearing the discussion between George Martin, the string players and Paul McCartney about the use of vibrato in Eleanor Rigby. Also, the difference in effect between the legato arpeggio at the beginning and the severe staccato of the released version. The now famous scrap of Lennon singing an early sketch that would become Yellow Submarine which has him sounding (in theme and voice) more like his Plastic Ono Band persona. George's acoustic tryout of Love You To with Paul on harmonies shows a level of experimentation that didn't make it through (particularly with Paul's harmony which ends up gilding a lily). The backing track of Rain will make you stop anything you are doing. It's the original speed but sounds accelerated (especially McCartney's gymnastic bass playing). Probably the most notable inclusion is Got to Get You into My Life with an overdriven guitar playing the brass parts. It's left quite skeletal and would have needed something extra (which it got at the expense of the guitars) but it recalls how Keith Richards, trying to beef up the sound of Satisfaction put on the now famous fuzz pedal riff where he imagined a brass section.
This section of the larger release can get tiresome with repetition of material and sketch-level attempts but it does provide good access to a band that was breaking well out of the outer shell to make music that did not depend on being played live.
ATMOS
Overall, this is a further expansion to the stereo mix. As on the better Atmos presentations of recent years like Plastic Ono Band or Let it Be, there is almost no gimmickry: the instrument positions are established and kept according to an imagined floorplan. But this is Revolver with its sound effects and backwards instruments and all that malarky. Where warranted, the Beatles' own creative expansions have been followed.
If you can imagine a more immersive stereo experience with the occasional liberty, you've got it. I'll single out the vocal harmonies which shine more strongly than on any other mix, sound effects like those in Yellow Submarine are given the gimmicky status around the stage as they might (see also the instrumental/tape clip segment in Mr Kite on Pepper) and the more lysergically inspired ones in Tomorrow Never Knows fly around the stage like glowing seagulls or fidgeting orchestra sections. The latter has some of the most pleasurable creative panning for a psychedelic piece I've experienced. Lennon's calling vocal, first clear and clean and then more strange and sinister through the Leslie speaker declaims the meditation as sprites and spectres fly around him.
I took some pains to get in front of this mix as it has only been released to streaming. Not all streaming services allow Dolby Atmos to my setup. Android TV and Samsung soundbar both with built-in Dolby Atmos. The only service I could find that allowed it was Tidal. It just worked.
MONO
If you want to hear Revolver as The Beatles imagined and intended you need to hear it in mono. Mono doesn't mean dull or boxed in, it just means all the music comes out on one channel and so has been subjected to painstaking tone shaping and compression so that it sounds balanced and clear. Why bother with it in 2022? Purism be damned, for starters, couldn't care less, but put the mono on through speakers, move away from them and it won't even occur to you. You're hearing a band at its peak whose sound has been nourished by one of the great record producers and engineering teams available. It's a great record with a lot of punchy rock, popping orchestration, weird soundscapes and always compelling vocals. That's the way most people heard it to begin with and they were stopped in their tracks by the invention, the cheek and the strangeness. On that, the mix itself is different, with some extra parts or effects that didn't make it on to the stereo mix.
It's how I first heard it (a sister's friend had an original mono copy at a time before the reissue was available in the late 70s) and am always content with. Why mono, now, though, in 2022? Because of the abovementioned but also because you might gain some extra insight on how production and arrangement work together to create that odd sense of space when only one channel is available. The stabbing rhythm guitar of Taxman, the Psycho strings of Eleanor Rigby, the snakey guitar riff of She Said She Said, the big brass of Got to Get You Into My Life, the sweetness of the French horn in For No One, and so on, all come through with such clarity and position that your brain makes spatial sense of it and assigns physical spaces for the sounds.
And the history of it shouldn't be dismissed. In 1966 mono was as normal as DVD was until Blu-Ray in the 2000s. Why get a new machine just to hear it from one more speaker? Both the equipment and the records were more expensive with stereo which seemed to be only for tossers with money better spent on life in general. And they who thought so back then weren't entirely silly considering how absurd a lot of the stereo mixing was then. If you listen to original stereo mixes of any Beatles disc until the White Album you'd best not do it with headphones as the extreme panning (voices in one channel and instruments in the other) with give you a headache.
The mono mix here is taken directly from the original master without any extra EQ or compression. In fact, if you look at the wave of any of the tracks you'll see that it's very pleasantly undulating within a narrow range, not brick walled up to the extreme. If you hear it digitally, you are hearing the cleanest it is going to be. If you are listening on the vinyl release it has only gone through analogue paths (I have no interest in the LP version of this but that tidbit is worth a mention).
EP
Paperback Writer and Rain formed the sides of one of two singles the band released at this time (the other being uncharacteristic album tracks Yellow Submarine and Eleanor Rigby). Both of these songs are among the finest of the band's singles for a few reasons. Neither has a young love theme and both rock in ways unusual for the time. Paperback Writer occasioned the innovation of a massive diaphragmed microphone (an inverted speaker) to cope with the extra bass the band wanted. Rain was recorded a full tone higher than the released version as they wanted the sound to be heavier than usual. The EP section of the Super Deluxe release has the original mono single mixes and a new stereo mix for each. The mono originals are tight and rocky and untouched. The stereo mixes are pleasantly drier of reverb than more recent attempts to excite them into the world of now. Both sound great.
WHICH VERSION DID I BUY?
The Super Deluxe but as a purchased download, not a physical box set. Look around for an online hi-res store as there are a few good deals happening.
While initially excited by news that one of my most beloved records was to get the same wonderful treatment as the later albums, I was crestfallen to learn of the bizarre decision to leave the Blu-Ray disc out of the Super Deluxe box. It might have followed the example of the others with a hi-res presentation of at least the stereo and mono mixes as well as a surround mix. That would have sealed the deal on my buying the box but without that one disc it became an overpriced lower-resolution version with a book. The only reason I'd bother with it in the future is if it were to be discounted by about 50%. So, I did what I normally do apart from the box, and buy a download of the whole thing at higher resolution to put on my various devices have been happy to listen that way.
If a Blu-Ray were to appear with these features or even just the surround mix, I'd get that but I suspect that the longer game of keeping it to subscription services means that fans will be expected to pay for it repeatedly which answers to the unnecessary extra income for the representatives of the biggest music act in history. It saddens me as it would be something that many people could accessibly enjoy but has been kept relatively exclusive. This was not Giles Martin's nor Sam Okell's decision but the corporation that manages the material. Maybe it's just an overstatement on my part but it breaks the legacy of value that the band began with.
Speaking of value, one of the lamest brained decisions in the release was to match the CD and vinyl versions disc for disc. CDs can hold a mass more than an old LP but there must have been the concern in these days of analogue as snake oil that drove this utter bullshit. It was the same with the Let it Be Super Deluxe. The EP tracks could have been put on a sessions CD which would have left ample room for a Blu-Ray. Not to be and for the worst reasons.
EPILOGUE
This record was a grail for me. I'd seen it in a vintage ad in an old magazine. For some reason they showed the cover in negative and listed the titles only of the single (Eleanor Rigby and Yellow Submarine). At the time, there was no reissue of this one. Pepper was never out of print, along with all of the albums from it to Let it Be. The main Beatles records everyone else seemed to have were the compilations generally known as the Red and Blue albums. But I wanted the originals. There seemed to be a kind of parental caution against pursuing them, as though the music would release the wolves of the mountains and lay waste the greater Townsville municipal area.
My sister Anita's closest friend was Penny and in her family's record collection was discovered a copy, after I'd brought it up in conversation, of the original mono mix of Revolver. Penny happily lent it to me for taping. I held it for many minutes, examining the strange cartoon collage cover and the cover where the band in stark black and white were all wearing glasses and smiling at each other rather than outward to their fans. The background of the photograph is utterly lightless and gave off a sense of sinister invention.
Then I had to put it on and listen. This was May Holidays 1976 so I had the whole morning to hear and hear again the music on this disc, the harsh satire of Taxman, the pitiless description of loneliness that followed, the breezy but oddly unsettling ode to staying in bed, George's dark mooded song of sexual opportunity, Paul's spooky ballad of ubiquity, Ringo's goofy kid's song, the acerbic John song about tripping and the things people say, Paul's goodtime summer song, the odd one about birds and possessions, Paul's heartfelt breakup number, the snappy one about the feelgood doctor, George's mini epic with the teetering pitch about uncertain communication, Paul's big brassy love song and the words from our sponsor, The Tibetan Book of the Dead that featured vocal manipulation, imps, goblins and sprites of sound flew out of the darkness where the guitars were so disorientated they played backwards, as John's sharp voice got sharper still with processing before it all collapsed into chaos.
I had never heard a record like it. It made me not want to be a rock star but a composer. As it was in mono (I had no idea how precious that mix was) it played perfectly in the cruddy old tape player I used to listen in my room. And there, with the curtains closed against the light and heat, I heard it many times as though falling into a meditative rite, and wondered how I might try, just try to do something as bold.
There's just one more thing.
People make a lot of the bare three year gap between the first album, Please Please Me, and Revolver, considering it astonishing that a band could develop so quickly, but it's really not that simple. Yes, PPM was recorded within twenty four hours of studio time in 1963 and Revolver for much longer in 1966, but it's not just three albums, it's not just three years and it's not just some godlike talents casting gifts of music down from a mountaintop. It's two and a bit years in Hamburg learning their instruments, performance and stamina in an often hostile environment and getting skins of iron. It's four years of playing to increasingly massive audiences, getting wealthy and feted by circles of privilege and influence. All of those years saw the development of the creative and social motion within the band including legendarily tough competitive filtration of material and ideas. It's all those years being fed with the most innovative culture that could be served them in their social holiness, the youthful urge to press on to newer and more interesting means of expression, and the permanently blank cheque that a savvy record company gave them to get in and play. Yes, it was as basic as Love Me Do back in the uniform collarless suit days but by 1966, The Beatles were the most privileged musicians on the face of the earth with no barriers to new cultural experience nor any forces outside the band to prevent them from doing exactly what they wanted. Revolver is the culmination of that, its celebration and boast. It is the big bang from which the cosmos of ever more expansive riches flowed, until they collapsed and went their own ways. Yes, there was good music from them before this album but there hadn't been a record by them that tried so much to the extent that you have to think of the tracks that are plain rock songs rather than expansions of the pallet or outright innovations. After this one the greatness was assumed, expected. All that in thirty six minutes of playing time.